High Employee Turnover? Implement the Stay Interview Strategy

Keep your best employees: Stop the resignation avalanche with this trick

Surabhi Shenoy profile photo
Surabhi Shenoy

2x Exit · Entrepreneur · Creator of CEO Mastery

Did you know businesses in the United States alone lose up to $1.8 trillion annually due to lost productivity from high employee turnover?

The same trend is reflected the world over.

Here’s a strategy I’ve used repeatedly, and now you can, to ensure it doesn’t happen in your company.

I led my tech company for 20 years. While many other tech founders complained about attrition, we were blessed with a high retention rate and stability in the team.

We never measured attrition. Why? Because I firmly believe that energy flows where attention goes. Instead of fixating on losses, we focused on retention. It’s a subtle shift, but it made all the difference.

Our success hinged on three key factors:

  1. A rock-solid HR team that masterfully balanced business goals with employee well-being.
  2. A dedicated “fun committee” that took employee engagement seriously (so seriously, in fact, that it became a running joke).
  3. A proactive approach to nurturing employee relationships.

Let me share a hard truth: Nothing stings an employee more than leadership suddenly waking up when they resign. Scrambling to offer pay hikes and better opportunities is a weak move driven by fear. It puts your company on the back foot, and trust me, even your HR team dreads those conversations.

The solution?

Stay ahead of the curve by being proactive and nurturing relationships. This is where the strategy comes in: Stay Interviews.

What exactly is a Stay Interview?

Unlike Exit interviews that happen too late, Stay Interviews are proactive conversations that can significantly boost retention and engagement.

They help address issues before they become deal-breakers.

A Stay Interview is a structured discussion between an HR person (or manager) and a valued employee, focused on understanding what keeps them engaged and what might cause them to leave.

It’s an opportunity to:

  • Gauge employee satisfaction
  • Identify potential issues early
  • Show employees you value their input
  • Strengthen the manager-employee relationship

By implementing Stay Interviews, you’re not just reacting to problems – you’re actively working to create an environment where your best talent wants to stay and grow.

Implementing Stay Interviews:

As a founder, I highly recommend conducting a few interviews yourself, alongside HR. It’s an eye-opening experience that can provide invaluable insights into your company culture.

To make the most of Stay Interviews, consider these key aspects:

1. Timing and Frequency:

  • Conduct them bi-annually (consider creating a dashboard)
  • Schedule during neutral periods, not immediately after performance reviews

2. Who Should Conduct Them:

  • HR dept along with reporting manager
  • To get the most out of Stay interviews, conduct them by someone the employee trusts.

Now, let’s look at what to ask:

3. Essential Questions:

  • What do you look forward to when you come to work each day?
  • What talents are not being used in your current role?
  • What would make your job more satisfying?
  • How do you like to be recognized?
  • What would entice you to leave?

There can (should) be more!

To help you get started, I’ve created a comprehensive category-based Stay Interview Template. Download the Stay Interview Template for Free

Founder’s Tip: I always end my Stay Interviews with this question: ‘If you were in my shoes, what’s one thing you would change about the company?’ This often yields the most insightful responses.

To ensure your Stay Interviews are effective, keep these best practices in mind

  • Practice active listening
  • Seek to act on the feedback
  • Create a safe, open environment
  • Take notes and follow up on commitments

And watch out for these common pitfalls:

  • Making promises you can’t keep
  • Failing to follow through on actionable items
  • Turning Stay interview into a performance review

Finally, to gauge the success of your Stay Interview program, track these metrics before and after implementation:

  • Internal promotion rates
  • Employee retention rate
  • Engagement scores
  • Productivity levels

Reviewing and Acting on Feedback

The power of Stay Interviews lies not in conducting them but in demonstrating that you’ve truly listened and are committed to positive change.

  • Analyze the Data: Look for common themes across interviews.
  • Prioritize Actions: Create an action plan addressing key concerns.
  • Communicate and Implement Changes: Share a summary of general findings with all employees and implement changes visibly and promptly.
  • Follow Up Individually: Circle back to interviewed employees within a month to discuss specific actions taken based on their feedback.
  • Improve Continuously: Regularly assess the effectiveness of implemented changes and adjust your approach based on results and new feedback.

Remember, when you follow through on what you learn, you show your team that their input matters. This builds trust and opens up communication.

In my two decades at the helm, I learned that our most valuable asset isn’t our product, or even customers – it’s our people.

Stay Interviews is your investment and commitment to creating a workplace where people want to stay and grow.

They’ve been a game-changer for me, and I’m confident they can be for you too.

Infographic explaining stay interview strategy to reduce employee turnover, covering proactive retention, interview timing, key questions, common pitfalls, and success metrics
Founder’s Challenge:
Commit to conducting Stay Interviews with your top 5 employees in the next 30 days. Share your biggest insight with me – I’d love to hear how it goes.

Here’s to building teams that stick,

Surabhi

Ready to master your CEO game?
Here are 2 ways I can help

1) Elite CEO Coaching:

Strategic support to scale systematically 
Book Your Free Clarity Call 

2) 1:1 Strategy Session

One focused hour. Clear action plan. Immediate implementation. 
Get a Power Hour With Me

Articles to Deepen Your Understanding

Title
Read Time

A truck driver bet on Sam Walton. 20 years later, retired with $700,000

6 min

People say, “You are a strong woman”

6 min

The Best Meeting I Hosted

4 min

How to Work With a Co-Founder (Part 2)

6 min

Choosing Co-founder? Read This First

7 min

Celebrating 70 editions + a gift for you

5 min

You’re Running 2 Businesses, But Managing Only One

6 min

Your Team Isn’t Telling You the Truth

4 min

How to share your doubts with team without losing authority

4 min

How to Reduce Key-Person Risk in Delivery

5 min
Title
Read Time

Radical Candor for Founders: How to Care Deeply and Challenge Directly

4 min

Surrounded by Idiots: A Founder’s Guide to Managing Different Personalities

4 min

The Godfather: Leadership Lessons Every Founder Should Learn

4 min

From Small to Significant: How Good to Great Principles Scale Self-Funded Companies

5 min
Title
Read Time

Scaling Without Burnout: Building a Buyable Business Without Chasing Endless Capital

1 min

Unlocking Creativity in Business: From Founder Mindset to Innovative Execution

1 min

From Engineer to Entrepreneur to CEO Coach: Lessons in Building and Exiting Businesses

1 min

Building Buyable Businesses: Scaling, Exiting, and Doing It on Your Own Terms

2 min

CEO Mastery Newsletter

Get the exact strategies I used to scale and exit two 7-figure businesses — in your inbox every Thursday. 4-min read.

Share this article

MORE FROM CEO MASTERY

I under-invested in demand for years

This is Part 2 of a 4-part series studying Sam Walton — focusing on how his thinking applies to pricing, distribution, incentives, and growth.  Part 1 : How Sam Walton Thinks Part 2: How Founders Can Use His Thinking (this edition) Part 3: How Sam Walton Built a Team That

I studied Sam Walton for months. Here’s how his mind worked

This is Part 1 of a 4-part series studying Sam Walton. This series shows how Sam Walton made decisions, from running a single store to building a business that now does over $600 billion in revenue. Part 1 : How Sam Walton Thinks (this edition)Part 2: How Founders Can Use

Don't miss the next insight

Join thousands of founders building with clarity, not chaos.

Scroll to Top
I will never spam or sell your info. Ever.